Shop All - Dairy

Quick view Add to Cart

Strawberries & Cream Frozen Fruit Bars 4ct - 8.25oz

$7.29

JonnyPops
Quick view Add to Cart

Kids Organic Chocolate Protein Shake - 4pk- 8.25 fl oz ea

$9.99

Orgain
Out of stock

Quick view Out of stock

Vanilla Bean Yoghurt Single Serve - 4.5oz

$1.99

Noosa Yoghurt
Sale

Quick view Add to Cart

Passion Fruit & Mango Skyr Yogurt - 5.3oz

$3.49 $2.44

Icelandic Provisions
Quick view Add to Cart

Kefir - Whole Plain - 32oz

$6.79

Lifeway
Sale

Quick view Add to Cart

Whole Milk Plain Skyr Yogurt - 24oz

$6.99 $6.29

Siggi's
Quick view Add to Cart

Frozen Rainbow Fruit Stacks Water Pop 8ct - 14.8oz

$7.99

JonnyPops
Quick view Add to Cart

Tropical Paradise Punch Water Pop 8ct - 14.8oz

$7.99

JonnyPops
Sale

Quick view Add to Cart

Charcuterie Turnkey Bundle

$82.00 $60.99

TC Farm
Quick view Add to Cart

Peanut Butter Dark Chocolate Keto Nut & Seed Bar - 1.23oz

$2.19

Munk Pack
Quick view Add to Cart

Farmhouse Cheddar Block - 7oz

$6.99

Sartori
Sale

Out of stock

Quick view Out of stock

Oat Milk Creamer - Unsweetened - 32oz

$6.59 $5.49

Sown
Sale

Out of stock

Quick view Out of stock

Vanilla Skyr Yogurt - 24oz

$10.99 $9.79

Painterland Sisters
Sale

Quick view Add to Cart

Honey Swirl Ice Cream Pint - 14oz

$7.99 $7.29

Ice Cream for Bears
Quick view Add to Cart

Unsweetened Coconut Plant-Based Beverage - 32fl oz

$4.29

Pacific Foods
Sale

Quick view Add to Cart

Maple Bourbon Goat Cheese Log - 4oz

$4.49 $3.59

Laclare Farms
Out of stock

Quick view Out of stock

Goat Cheese Colby Jack - 8oz

$8.49

Natural Valley
Quick view Add to Cart

Italian Limoncello Gelato - 30.4oz

$8.99

Cadia
Sale

Quick view Add to Cart

Creme Fraiche French Cultured Cream- 5oz

$4.99 $3.49

Bellwether Farms
Sale

Quick view Add to Cart

Lactose-Free Sour Cream - 12oz

$4.99 $4.29

Green Valley Creamery
Sale

Quick view Add to Cart

Lifeway Lowfat Blueberry Kefir - 32oz

$6.79 $5.89

Lifeway
Quick view Add to Cart

Muenster Slices - 6oz

$5.99

Organic Valley
Quick view Add to Cart

Free Range Duck Eggs - Half Dozen

$7.29

Graise Farm
Sale

Quick view Add to Cart

Pure Irish Salted Butter Sticks - 8oz

$6.49 $5.79

Kerrygold
Quick view Add to Cart

Smoky Cheddar Slices - 6oz

$6.99

Organic Valley
Quick view Add to Cart

Oval Brie Cheese - 7oz

$6.99

Supreme
Quick view Add to Cart

Gluten Free Plain Tortillas - 9oz

$8.39

Rudi's Bakery
Sale

Quick view Add to Cart

Whole Milk Peach Kefir - 32oz

$6.79 $5.89

Lifeway
Sale

Quick view Add to Cart

Whole Milk Plain Traditional Skyr Yogurt - 30oz

$9.99 $6.99

Icelandic Provisions
Sale

Quick view Add to Cart

Unsweetened Hazelnut Milk - 32fl oz

$6.99 $4.89

Elmhurst
Quick view Add to Cart

Brie Bites - 4.4oz

$7.99

Supreme
Quick view Add to Cart

Unsweetened Organic Coconut Milk - 32fl oz

$7.49

Califia
Quick view Add to Cart

Mozzarella Shreds - 6oz

$7.19

Rumiano Family
Quick view Add to Cart

Italian Mocha Gelato - 30.4oz

$8.99

Cadia
Quick view Add to Cart

Vanilla Bean Dipped Coconutmilk Bars 4ct - 9.2oz

$7.29

SO Delicious
Sale

Quick view Add to Cart

Grass Fed Probiotic Plain Whole Milk Yogurt - 24oz

$6.49 $3.89

Nancy's
Quick view Add to Cart

Mature Gouda Wedge Aged 6-9mo - 5oz

$6.99

Marieke Gouda
Sale

Quick view Add to Cart

Barista Edition Oatmilk - 32 oz

$4.99 $4.29

Oatly
Sale

Quick view Add to Cart

Cookie Dough French Ice Cream - 14oz

$7.99 $7.29

Ice Cream for Bears
Sale

Out of stock

Quick view Out of stock

Smoky Gouda Style Dairy Free Cheese Wedge - 4.2oz

$7.99 $5.59

Nuts for Cheese
Quick view Add to Cart

A to Z Ice Cream Mystery Bundle

$28.00

A to Z Creamery
Sale

Quick view Add to Cart

Tropical Freezie 10ct - 13.5 fl oz

$9.49 $7.29

Deebees Organic
Quick view Add to Cart

Clean Protein Shake - Creamy Chocolate Fudge 4pk - 11fl oz ea

$13.99

Orgain
Quick view Add to Cart

Goat Cheese Mild Cheddar - 8oz

$8.49

Natural Valley
Quick view Add to Cart

Montamore Cheddar Cheese Block - 7oz

$6.99

Sartori
Sale

Quick view Add to Cart

Quail Eggs Antibiotic Free- 15ct

$5.99 $5.49

Manchester Farms
Quick view Add to Cart

Pepper Jack Slices - 6oz

$6.49

Rumiano Family
Quick view Add to Cart

Strawberry Yoghurt Single Serve - 4.5oz

$1.99

Noosa Yoghurt
Sale

Quick view Add to Cart

Cookies and Cream French Ice Cream - 14oz

$7.99 $7.29

Ice Cream for Bears
Sale

Quick view Add to Cart

Peach Yoghurt Single Serve - 4.5oz

$1.99 $1.39

Noosa Yoghurt
Quick view Add to Cart

Merlot BellaVitano Cheese Wedge - 5.3oz

$6.99

Sartori
Quick view Add to Cart

Unsalted Butter Block 95% Grass Fed - 8oz

$6.99

TGF
Quick view Add to Cart

Chevre Natural Goat Cheese - 4oz

$4.49

Laclare Farms
Quick view Add to Cart

Italian Gelato Pistachio - 30.4oz

$8.99

Cadia
Quick view Add to Cart

Mixed Berries & Acai Skyr Yogurts 4pk - 21.2oz

$7.99

Siggi's
Quick view Add to Cart

Passion Fruit Sorbet - 16oz

$7.49

Pitaya Foods
Quick view Add to Cart

Dragonfruit Sorbet - 16oz

$6.99

Pitaya Foods
Quick view Add to Cart

Old World Cheddar Block- 7oz

$6.99

Sartori
Sale

Quick view Add to Cart

5% Milkfat Plain Greek Yogurt - 32fl oz

$10.99 $9.89

Fage Total Greek
Quick view Add to Cart

Garlic and Herb BellaVitano Cheese Wedge - 5.3oz

$6.99

Sartori
Quick view Add to Cart

Italian Macchiato Caramel Gelato - 30oz

$8.99

Cadia
Quick view Add to Cart

SarVecchio Parmesan Cheese Wedge - 5.3oz

$6.99

Sartori
Quick view Add to Cart

Young Gouda Wedge Aged 2-4mo - 5oz

$6.99

Marieke Gouda
Quick view Add to Cart

Blue Cheese Wedge - 8 oz

$2.99

BelGioioso
Sale

Quick view Add to Cart

Oat Milk Creamer - Sweet and Creamy - 32oz

$6.59 $5.49

Sown
Quick view Add to Cart

Sharp Cheddar Cheese Bar - 8oz

$8.49

Rumiano Family
Quick view Add to Cart

Vanilla Blueberry Almond Superfood Cereal - 11oz

$7.99

Purely Elizabeth
Sale

Quick view Add to Cart

Sugar Cones Rolled Style 12ct - 4.6oz

$5.99 $5.29

Let's Do Organics
Out of stock

Quick view Out of stock

Blue Cheese Crumbles - 4oz

$5.99

Organic Valley
Quick view Add to Cart

Hazelnut Creamer - 24oz

$6.99

Chobani
Quick view Add to Cart

Alphonso Mango Mochi Ice Cream 6pk - 7.5oz

$6.99

Bubbie's
Sale

Quick view Add to Cart

Cake Style Ice Cream Cones - 12ct

$4.99 $4.29

Let's Do Organics
Out of stock

Quick view Out of stock

Garlic Herb Goat Cheese Log - 4oz

$4.49

Laclare Farms
Sale

Out of stock

Quick view Out of stock

Un-Brie-Lievable Dairy Free Cheese Wedge - 4.2oz

$7.99 $6.99

Nuts for Cheese
Out of stock

Quick view Out of stock

Chocolate Fudge and Oat Milk Frozen Bars 4ct - 8.25oz

$5.99

JonnyPops
Quick view Add to Cart

Vegan Mature Cheddar Slices - 7.05oz

$6.49

Violife
Quick view Add to Cart

Acai Berry Sorbet - 16oz

$6.99

Pitaya Foods
Quick view Add to Cart

Creamy Original Chao Slices - 7oz

$5.99

Field Roast
Quick view Add to Cart

Garlic and Herb Cheese Spread - 5.3oz

$6.99

Boursin
Quick view View Options

Taco Night Bundle

MSRP:

Was:

Now: $27.89 - $31.49

TC Farm
Quick view Add to Cart

European Style A2 Sour Cream - 8 oz

$7.89

Alexandre Family Farm
Sale

Quick view Add to Cart

Vanilla Skyr Yogurt 4ct - 21.2oz

$7.99 $7.19

Siggi's
Quick view Add to Cart

Honey Peanut Butter Superfood Cereal - 11oz

$7.99

Purely Elizabeth
Quick view Add to Cart

Strawberry Mochi Ice Cream 6pk - 7.5oz

$6.99

Bubbie's
Quick view Add to Cart

Strawberry Sunrise Smoothie Cup - 8 oz

$5.89

Live More Organics
Sale

Out of stock

Quick view Out of stock

Whole Milk Vanilla Skyr Yogurt - 24oz

$6.99 $5.59

Siggi's
Sale

Quick view Add to Cart

Aged Cheddar Cheese Snacking Sticks - 6 oz

$6.49 $5.99

Kerrygold
Quick view Add to Cart

Coconut Sorbet - 16oz

$7.49

Pitaya Foods
Quick view Add to Cart

Mustard Melange Gouda Wedge - 5oz

$6.99

Marieke Gouda
Quick view View Options

Peanut Butter Chocolate Pretzel Pie

MSRP:

Was:

Now: $38.00 - $42.00

Ben The Baker
Sale

Out of stock

Quick view Out of stock

Protein Plus Reduced Fat Milk, Lactose-Free - 48 fl oz

$7.49 $5.24

Organic Valley
Out of stock

Quick view Out of stock

Grass Fed Vanilla Greek Yogurt - 16oz

$7.49

Maple Hill Creamery
Quick view Add to Cart

Matcha Green Tea Mochi Ice Cream 6pk - 7.5oz

$6.99

Bubbie's
Quick view Add to Cart

Organic 2% Reduced Fat Milk - 64oz

$6.99

Organic Valley
Quick view Add to Cart

Organic Plant-Based Butter Sticks - 16 oz

$6.49

Melt
Quick view Add to Cart

Holy Trinity Melange Gouda Wedge - 5oz

$6.99

Marieke Gouda
Quick view Add to Cart

A to Z Salted Caramel - Quart

$24.00

A to Z Creamery
Quick view Add to Cart

Berry Bliss Smoothie Cup - 7 oz

$5.89

Live More Organics
Quick view Add to Cart

All Natural Mayonnaise - 16oz

$5.99

Cadia
Quick view Add to Cart

Aloha Greens Smoothie Cup - 7.5 oz

$5.89

Live More Organics